AirTree Ventures Crypto 101

1
Crypto 101
September 2021
“Into the Ether”
by Beeple
Day #4917
16.10.20
ARTIST’S NOTES:
Down the rabbit hole
Kevin Lu & Andrew Yeo

2
Disclaimer
The purpose of this presentation is to provide general information only, and nothing in it constitutes (i) an offer or disclosure document of any kind in
relation to, (ii) a recommendation to buy, (iii) an offer to sell, (iv) a solicitation of an offer to buy, (v) advice in relation to or (vi) an endorsement of any
securities, financial instruments, financial products, or financial services. An offer or invitation will only be extended to a person if the person has
first satisfied AirTree that the offer or invitation would not require AirTree or its related entities to prepare a disclosure document or product
disclosure statement (each as defined in the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)) or equivalent document in other jurisdictions or require the Fund to be
registered as a managed investment scheme under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
To the extent permitted by law, none of AirTree, its related entities or their respective directors, officers, partners, employees, affiliates, shareholders
or agents makes any representation, guarantee or warranty (express or implied) as to, or accepts responsibility for, the accuracy or completeness of
the information contained in this presentation. None of AirTree, its related entities or their respective directors, officers, partners, employees,
affiliates, shareholders or agents has any responsibility to notify any person of any inaccuracies or omissions in information contained in this
document or to update this document in any way.
This presentation has been prepared without any knowledge or consideration of the investment objectives, financial situation, taxation position or
other particular needs or requirements of any recipient and should not be relied on for the purposes of making any investment. Each of AirTree, its
related entities and their respective directors, officers, partners, employees, affiliates, shareholders and agents disclaims to the fullest extent
permitted by law all liability, direct or indirect, for any loss or damage suffered by any person (regardless of the basis on which such liability may
arise, including out of negligence or otherwise) arising out of, or in connection with, any use or reliance on this presentation.
AirTree and its related bodies corporate reserve all copyright, trademark, patent, intellectual and other property rights in the information contained in
the document. Any unauthorised use or reproduction is strictly prohibited.

3
Contents
1. The basics – why was it created & what is it?
2. Story of webs and waves
3. Taxonomy of crypto land
4. Crypto Business Models
5. Regulatory responses
6. Differences in investing in crypto vs regular start-ups
7. Glossary & Resources
“Tinct Formation Discovery”
by Beeple
15.06.15

5
01.Basics – the why
Crypto was initially a
response to the flaws of
global financial and
government systems
• ~20% of the world’s GDP (US$16T) is dedicated to moving
money around.
• >2B people unbanked worldwide
• Money movement requires trust of centralized third parties who
didn’t prove so trustworthy in the GFC
• Governments seizing assets/property in some countries
• Hyper inflation – you can’t always rely on government backed
currency (e.g., Zimbabwe)
• (Large) funds are not accessible when banks are closed
• Cross-border transaction fees are expensive
• Lengthy time required to execute transactions

6
01.Basics – the what
Crypto – refers to digital
currency underpinned
by cryptography and
blockchain technology
Cryptocurrencies have these attributes
• universally accessible (with internet)
• cannot be faked
• the record of transactions is public
• cannot be altered retrospectively, and
• has limited supply (thus is deflationary)1
1. Not always the case

7
What is a blockchain ?
• Level 1 - Basic explanation: Think of it as an
open list of data, shared by a network of people.
New additions to the list needs to be validated by
participants in the network. New additions cannot
be changed once added. All the functionality of
the list is secured by maths & computer science.
• Level 2 - Geeky explanation1: A virtual computer
that runs on top of a network of physical
computers that provides strong, auditable,
game-theoretic guarantees that the code it runs
will continue to operate as designed.
1. Simple definition of a computer: A system that can a) store data, and b) can perform operations on said data

8
Credits: Patrick Rivera
Let’s back track and look at
traditional client – server
architecture. Here, traditional
servers are closed systems
owned by a company.
Example
Internet Corp

9
The internet is basically
just a bunch of these
closed systems
interacting with each
other

10
There are trade-offs with
the traditional client-
server architecture
Pros
• Network effects
• Scalability
• Faster Iteration
Cons
• Monopolistic behaviour
• Centralized control
• 3rd-parties need permission to
integrate
• Single point of failure

11
Now let’s look at
decentralized
architecture & how it
solves for client – server
model issues
Blockchain are peer-to-peer networks

12
Clients can send, receive,
and read transactions or
information
Transactions include
transferring cryptocurrency
(e.g., bitcoin) or assets
between client x and client y

13
Validators check that transactions
are correct by solving
cryptographic (math) problems
which use computer power.
Consensus between validators is
needed for transactions to be
recorded on the blockchain.
Validators receive rewards like
bitcoin for their work

14
Consensus refers to when most
validators agree on the right
transactions to add to the
blockchain ledger. The most
common consensus methods are
Proof of Stake and Proof of Work
Proof of work Proof of stake
Energy consumption High Low
Participants “Miners” “Stakers”
Reward selection
To add new blocks, miners
compete using their
computer’s processing power
to solve difficult math puzzles
Creator of a new block is
randomly chosen among
stakers by an algorithm.
Amount staked increases
chances of selection
Validation
All miners compete to solve
cryptographic puzzle to
validate the transaction
Set validators participate in a
consensus algorithm to vote
on the next block to be forged
Rewards
The first miner to solve the
puzzle is given a reward for
their work
No block reward. The
randomly selected staker
takes the block’s pooled
transaction fees
Protocol

15
There are trade-offs
with decentralised
architecture as well
Pros
• Decentralized governance
• No single point of failure
• Each client node owns their data
• Global access
• 3rd parties can integrate w/o permission
Cons
• Challenging to scale
• Security bugs are near impossible to
revert
• Proof of work consensus consumes a lot
of energy (but Proof of Stake solves this)

17
02.Story of webs and waves
Let’s start with the era
of the webs

18
Web 1.0 (1993 – 2002)
• Static websites
• Portals
• Directories
• Email/Chat
• Physical goods marketplaces
• Low bandwidth
• Limited hardware

19
Web 2.0 (2002 - 2018)
• Social
• Mobile
• Cloud computing and SaaS
• Gig economy marketplaces
• Centralized web

20
Web 3.0 (2018 - ?)
• Decentralised web + in-built payment rails
• Smart contracts
• DeFi
• NFT standards
• Metaverses
• Decentralised Autonomous Organisations
(DAOs)

21
Web 3.0 is Crypto
• Decentralizing control and reducing intermediaries
• Using technology to help the disadvantaged
• Fixing what’s wrong with the internet and finance today

22
Crypto’s story has played out
in 4 waves, each with similar
underlying dynamics:
“Bull Run”
by Beeple
Day #4951
19.11.20
Price Interest Activity
Source: a16z, AirTree Ventures analysis

23
Wave 1: (2010-2012)
• Bitcoin
• Miners
• Centralised exchanges
(Coinbase, Mt Gox, Kraken)
• Focus on wallet technologies
Sources: Chris Dixon (a16z), data from Github, Pitchbook, Twitter and Subreddits

24
Wave 2: (2012-2016)
• Ethereum started which
gave birth to smart contracts
• Mt.Gox Hack (2014)
• Developer activity kicked off
and sustained despite price
declines
A Smart Contract is a programmatic agreement to exchange goods, services, or
money that will automatically execute, without third party oversight, so long
as established criteria are met. This allows agreements between parties to be
executed without a central authority or legal system. It also enables things like
trading of crypto assets or liquidations of loan collateral to happen autonomously
without intermediaries.

25
Wave 3: (2017-2019)
• Start of DeFi (Maker)
• New focus on interoperability
• ICO mania
• NFTs and gaming
• Crypto winter
• Birth of stable-coins

26
Putting the 3
waves together,
we see
consistent
growth driven
by a feedback
loop between
interest &
innovation
CAGR: Compound Annual Growth Rate

27
Sources: DeFi Pulse, Dune Analytics, AirTree Ventures analysis
Wave 4: 2020-? Seeds planted in the 2017 wave are seeing mainstream
adoption, two main use cases being:
1. DeFi & Stablecoins
This takes crypto beyond just being a
currency, enabling financial services
(insurance, loans, exchanges,
derivatives) in a decentralized manner.
Emergence of scalable and fast L1 and
L2 chains, and stablecoins have boosted
DeFi adoption
2. NFTs & Gaming
Files that live on a blockchain that
can prove ownership of an asset,
hugely beneficial to the issue of
attribution in the world of art and gaming.
Key Projects:
Key Projects:
Ethereum

28
From the outside, it
looks like crypto is just
cycles of speculation

29
But insiders realize
each cycle brings the
capital needed to
invest in critical
infrastructure
Critical Infrastructure already built:
ü Layer 1 blockchains (e.g., Ethereum, Solana)
ü Developer tools
ü Decentralized exchanges
ü Smart wallets
ü Storage protocols
ü Stablecoins
ü Lending protocols

31
03.Taxonomy of crypto land
There are 5 layers to a
virtual blockchain
computer
Layer 4
Application Layer (Wallets & Interfaces)
Layer 3
Smart Contracts
Layer 21
Computation Enhancement
Layer 1
Consensus & Settlement
Layer 0
Hardware & Networking
1. Only applies to earlier Proof of Work L1 chains like Bitcoin and Ethereum. Does not apply to new iterations of chains like Solana, Avalanche and Algorand which are scalable and fast

32
L1 - L3 are at the
heart of crypto,
being the key
points of value
aggregation1
AirTree Ventures
Layer 4
Layer 3
Smart Contracts
Layer 2
Layer 1
Layer 0
Borrowing, saving crypto Decentralised exchange
Enable greater network transaction speed

33
Initially we thought most
of the value in web 3.0.
would be captured in L1
(Fat Protocol Thesis)1
1. Joel Monegro (ex USV) – originally published the thesis in 2016
e.g. HTTP & TCP/IP

34
But we realized we can
draw a protocol-
application boundary at
any level of abstraction1
1. Jake Brukman (CoinFund)

35
Longer term, we
see composability
being a key theme,
particularly in DeFi,
which may mean
more value, more
evenly distributed1
1. Johnson Nakano (CoinMonk)
Time
Value
Capture
(as
a
%
of
the
total
blockchain
ecosystem)
App App App
App App App
L1 protocol
L1 protocol
L2 protocol
L3 protocol
L3 protocol
App
App App
Platform
App
L1 protocol
L2 protocol

37
04.Crypto Business Models
Let’s focus on L1 – L3 that
make crypto possible,
L0 & L4 have more
traditional business
models
Layer 4
Layer 3
Smart Contracts
Layer 2
Layer 1
Layer 0
Source: a16z, AirTree Ventures update

38
Value capture at L1 & L3
are instances of
multi-sided platforms
What is a multi-sided platform?
• Common ground that enables interaction between
different types of participants to create value
Examples:
1. Bazaar - where merchants meet villagers
2. Uber – where drivers meet riders
3. App Store – where developers meet users
Source: a16z, AirTree Ventures update

39
L1 blockchains are generally
multi-sided platforms with 5
participants
1. Founder & Team build protocol
2. Investors may help fund project
3. Protocol generates some initial token value
4. Once token value exists, it creates incentive for validators to provide
computational resources for platform security and functionality.
5. Once platform exists, 3rd party developers are incentivised to create
useful applications (Layer 4)
6. Which bring utility to end users
7. As a result, community begins to form and grow
8. Which reinforces the protocol/token value
Source: Ali Yahya (a16z)

40
Core Layer 3 Business
Model
• Smart Contract exists in the middle
• Supply side provides/offers service
• Demand side pays for service
• Protocol Governance Token holders captures a
small share of the revenue
• All in a way which is automatic, no
intermediary/middle person

41
Case Study: Maker (L3)
• Ethereum based multi-sided platform with 5 participants,
split into 2 halves, one half offers a stable coin, the other
facilitates loans.
• Loan half: Composed of the Lender and Borrowers
• Stable coin ‘DAI’ half: As a result of the lending activity
(capital from lenders, and collateral from borrowers), a
stable USD pegged crypto currency is produced.
Collateral providers receive a stability fee that
continuously accrues as interest. Fees vary based on
collateral provided, and range between 1%-9% p.a.
• Keepers: Guardians of the network to ensure the network
is financially sound.
• MKR Holders: Serves as both governance (making sure
parameters of the network are sound, and risk is
managed), and mechanism for financial capital to enter
the network

42
Case Study: UniSwap (L3)
• Uniswap: Ethereum based decentralised exchange platform
with 3 sides. Was designed to function as a public good.
• Buyers and Sellers trade on the platform (just like they would
on Coinbase or Binance)
• Liquidity providers park their crypto assets (e.g., BTC, ETH,
DAI) in Uniswap liquidity pools in exchange for fees (~0.3%
per transaction). This allows buyers and sellers to always
trade with the pool rather than needing to wait for a counter
party to match their order.

5. Regulatory responses to
date

44
05.Regulation
Source: Elliptic
Most of the
western world is
moving towards
favourable crypto
regulation

45
05.Regulation
Source: Brian Brooks – Chief Legal Officer (Coinbase)
Key regulatory
tension points
globally
1. Crypto’s definition, particularly in being viewed as a security.
- Crypto can be classed as for personal use or as a security. If crypto is deemed to
be a security, this creates a reporting burden for projects. In the US, Safe Harbor
proposals and The Howey Test help crypto projects test if their tokens qualify as a
security or investment contract
1.
2. Decentralized exchanges and Know Your Customer (KYC)
- Exchanges need to KYC/AML, but there are many areas of the world where KYC
and AML infrastructure is not developed, preventing access to financial systems.
Embedded in crypto beliefs is global indiscriminate access, which goes against the
KYC/AML measures of traditional finance
3. Banning Crypto entirely to prevent capital flight
- This is largely only the case in countries with totalitarian regimes.

46
05.Regulation
Sources: WSJ, Financial Times, Coindesk, Reuters, Forbes
Latest
developments
1. U.S. Infrastructure Bill (August 2021)
- Bill passed which broadened the definition of broker to include cryptocurrency
developers, protocols and miners who will be required to report customer info to
the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
- An attempted amendment to distinguish developers had majority support but
was vetoed. Definitional issue remains, framework not workable let alone
enforceable. More work needs to be done before laws are legislated in circa 2023
2. China Crackdown heightened (June 2021)
- China’s ban on crypto miners and exchanges have been going on and off since
2018. It has been in part to stop capital flight, and in part to lower carbon
emissions from Bitcoin mining. China’s Bitmain supplies 65% of world’s mining
rigs. Miners like Bitmain have been transferring rigs out of China and are moving to
Kazakhstan, Mongolia and the US.
3. El Salvador’s world first adoption of Bitcoin as legal tender
- In June 2021, President Nayib Bukele said he will make BitCoin legal tender in El
Salvador, touting its potential to help Salvadorians living abroad send remittances
home.

47
05.Regulation
Crypto Rating
Council:
Group of 11 institutions
that have come
together to provide
risk-based scoring of
crypto tokens
CRC have put together a 36-question scorecard framework to determine
whether something is a security or not, and the riskiness of new crypto projects
Source: Brian Brooks – Chief Legal Officer (Coinbase)

48
05.Regulation
Sources: Comply Advantage, ATO, Coindesk.
Australia
has largely been
crypto friendly
(besides Libra),
and is
consistently
consulting with
industry to evolve
policy
• In Australia, cryptocurrencies are treated as property and subject to capital gains tax -
previously was subject to double taxation under GST
• Since 2018, all crypto exchanges in Australia must register with the Australian Transaction
Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC) - in compliance with AML/CTF 2006 Part 6A (Anti-
Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006).
• This rule requires entities acting as exchanges, or providing registrable exchange type
services to identity and verify their users, maintain records and comply with AML/CTF
reporting obligations
• Since May 2019, ASIC updated regulatory requirements for both ICOs and cryptocurrency
trading
• Select Committee on Australia as a Technology and Financial Centre has launched new
rounds of consultation to review the policy and provide consistency across a federal level
• One option is extending the nation’s fintech sandbox to include crypto projects. This
approach has been favoured in the FCA in the U.K. and the recently introduced fintech
sandbox in Spain
• Currently there is not yet a position on whether a “Governance Token” constitutes a security.
The token framework needs to be updated to distinguish between Governance and Utility
tokens
• Tax Treatment – if a crypto currency is held as an investment, investors are to entitled to the
personal use asset exemption, but if crypto is held for more than 12 months, investors may
be entitled to CGT discount to reduce a capital gain at disposal. See here for more detail

6. Differences in investing in
crypto vs regular start-ups

50
06.Differences between regular vs crypto startup investing
Token
vs
Equity
• Invest in equity, which increases in value as the cash flows
and impact of the business increases. Equity represents share
of ownership in an entity
• Often has investor protections e.g., pro rata rights and
liquidation preferences
• Equity pool is illiquid until liquidity event which is typically 4+
years from investment
• Includes ESOP, a stock option pool reserved for staff and hires
used to incentivize staff
• Equity is held by investors and staff
• Ownership stake can be diluted but pro-rata rights protects
from dilution
• Organization is governed by a central board and management
Regular Startups
• Invest in either Equity or Tokens but tokens are more
common, highly volatile and liquid
• Token value and economics vary but simplistically, token
value increases with usage of the product/Dapp/protocol and
high demand for the token relative to supply. Two types of
tokens:
• Governance token gives holders voting rights to
make changes to the project. Analogy in equity is
voting shares
• Utility tokens enable you to use, buy or earn in the
product e.g., Axie Play to Earn, DeFi rewards
• Equity protections and liquidity are similar to normal startups,
but should provide rights to tokens (not necessarily pro-rata)
• Tokens are split by ‘circulating supply’ and ‘non circulating’.
Circulating tokens are liquid in the secondary market. ‘Non
circulating’ are reserved or have vesting periods before they
are liquid
• Projects typically incentivize staff and community with tokens
• Tokens are held by investors, staff, treasury, users and the
community. Projects reward active contributors with more
tokens over time meaning passive investors are diluted over
time
• Projects are increasingly transitioning to Decentralised
Autonomous Organisations (DAOs), which is governed by
code that can only be changed via governance token holders
voting on community proposals
Crypto startups
AirTree Ventures

51
Source: AirTree Ventures, Modern Finance
Difference
in terms
• Investor protections: Includes pro-rata rights,
ROFR and liquidation preferences
• Investor liquidity: preference shares typically
issued at time of investment. Liquidations typically
happen 4+ years after investment at time of IPO,
M&A or secondary sale
• Employee stock and option vesting: typically 4
year vesting, 1 year cliff
• ESOP: Typically 10% of total capitalization is set
aside for staff options which is topped up in each
fundraising round
Regular Startups
• Investor protections:
• Equity: similar to regular startup but need to
ensure pro-rata rights to tokens
• Tokens: Not yet market standard to have
pro-rata rights to each new token issuance.
No liquidation preferences
• Investor liquidity:
• Equity: similar to left but also includes
conversion to tokens upon DAO transition
• Token: 3 year vesting period with 6-month
cliff and monthly vesting to avoid token
dumping
• Employee vesting:
• Equity: similar to startup but uncommon
• Token: similar vesting to investors above
• Core team tokens: Typically 10-20% of max
token supply are set aside for core team and hires
Crypto startups

52
Valuation
Methods
• Comparable multiples for enterprise value
• Revenue multiples for SaaS
• FUM multiples for investment tech
• EBITDA/CM multiples for later stage
scaleups
• Entry price based on % stake, exit revenue
and valuation scenarios. ”What you need to
believe to return the fund analysis”
Regular Startups
• Comparable multiples for token market
capitalisation
• Revenue multiple
• Total Value Locked multiple for DeFi
• Treasury reserve multiple
• Community and user base multiple
• The importance of % ownership of tokens in
circulation for fund return outcomes is TBD
but scenarios around future token supply
increases and expected token market cap
can help determine required % stake upon
investment
Crypto startups

Appendix: Glossary &
Resources

54
07.Crypto Jargon & Resources
Crypto Jargon
& Resources
Key resources for full in depth
glossary:
• Decryptionary.com
• Coinmarketcap.com
Learning resources:
• Decrypt
• A16z Crypto Canon
• Coinbase Learn
• Smart Contracts: Smart contract is defined as an programmatic agreement to exchange goods,
services, or money that will automatically execute, without third party oversight, so long
as established criteria are met.
• Mining: Mining is defined as the process of using computer power to solve a complex math
problem, review and verify information, and create a new record of transactions to be added to the
blockchain.
• Stable Coin: A cryptocurrency with extremely low volatility, sometimes used as a means of portfolio
diversification. Examples include gold-backed crypto – or fiat USD pegged crypto
• Tokens: A digital unit design with utility in mind, providing access, governance and use of a larger
crypto economic system
• Staking: Participating in a proof-of-stake (PoS) system to put your tokens in to serve as a validator to
the blockchain and receive rewards
• Zero Knowledge Proof: In cryptography, a ZKP enables one party to provide evidence that a
transaction or event happened without revealing private details of that transaction or event
• Scaling problem: the limitations of a blockchain’s transaction throughput and ability to have fast
and low cost transactions. I.e. Bitcoin processes 1 transaction per 15mins. Solana can do 50k per
second.
• Gas: A term used on the Ethereum platform that refers to a unit of measuring the computational
effort of conducting transactions or smart contracts, or launch Dapps in the Ethereum network. It is
the “fuel” of the Ethereum network.

55
End.
“Start Again”
by Beeple
12.01.19
@airtreevc
medium.com/airtree-venture
www.airtree.vc

AirTree Ventures Crypto 101

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (20)

Similar to AirTree Ventures Crypto 101

Similar to AirTree Ventures Crypto 101 (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

AirTree Ventures Crypto 101