Wednesday, April 24, 2024

EXPOSED: Google’s Go-To ‘Conservative’ Influencer List Who Claim ‘Big Tech Bias Is a Good Thing’

The National Pulse is today publishing a previously undisclosed “go to” list of “conservative” influencers that Big Tech firm Google uses to influence the political dynamics in Washington, D.C.

As the battle over Big Tech rages in Western capitals, The National Pulse was provided with an exclusive leak of the list of think tanks and activists who Google lobbyist Max Pappas reached out to on the back of the Federalist/Zero Hedge demonetization story.

Pappas – hired by Google in 2017 – took Google’s damage control messaging to nearly 100 influential figures on the right on Tuesday night.

The list (at the bottom of this article) includes key conservative influencers from major think tanks and publications – some of whom are believed to be beneficiaries of large Google donations.

Featured in the list are high-profile “conservative” organizations which solicit conservatives in the public for donations, all the while promoting Big Tech talking points, and/or taking grants from Big Tech companies which continue to censor conservatives online.

The Heritage Foundation, the CATO Institute, Americans for Tax Reform, R Street, the Competitive Enterprise Institute and more were named. The National Pulse reached out to both Google and Max Pappas before publication, though neither responded to our queries.

Some of these same influencers haven taken to social media in the past 24 hours to defend Google, or draw attention to the Google talking points on the back of the demonetization story.

The American Enterprise Institute (AEI) visiting scholar Mark Jamison tweeted ahead of the news an op-ed entitled “Big Tech is biased… and that’s a good thing”.

Jamison’s colleague at AEI, James Pethokoukis, appears to have taken his marching orders from Pappas’s email, hurriedly publishing an article on the AEI website endorsing Google’s actions, and claiming that “the ongoing conservative alarm about anti-conserative [sic] bias by America’s tech titans continues to fail that test [of reality]”.

In fact, Big Tech’s bias against conservatives is well documented.

Julian Sanchez – a CATO and Reason magazine contributor – stated “only conservative sites whine publicly about it, because other sites aren’t nursing a martyr complex”:

CATO’s Matthew Feeney – director of the think-tank’s “Emerging Technologies” project – used the opportunity to attack Fox News host Tucker Carlson and Senator Tom Cotton, while defending Google:

The Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI)’s Patrick Hedger, also a writer for the NeverTrump blog The Bulwark, took to the CEI website to defend a multitude of Big Tech companies.

He claims, despite evident monopolistic practices in the Big Tech sector: “these companies compete with one another in some way, suggesting that competition in the broader tech sector remains robust and lacking a justification for government investigation, let alone intervention.”

Hedger also pounced upon conservatives on Twitter:

https://twitter.com/PatHedger18/status/1273022533927931904?s=20

https://twitter.com/PatHedger18/status/1273015424234512385

The “actually“, anecdotal argument Hedger makes was never true, though it didn’t stop CEI’s Hedger digging himself deeper.

Mercatus’s Adam Thierer blasted conservatives who believe in regulating the tech sector, while Robert Winterton from an opaque group called ‘NetChoice’ based in a suite on K Street in Washington, D.C. attacked Sen Josh Hawley:

His colleague Chris Marchese agreed on cue.

Jessica Miers of the TechFreedom organization – another “think tank” – tweeted her boss Eric Goldman’s article out, sneeringly entitled: “Americans would probably love Section 230… if they understood it.”

The cast of characters willing to do Google’s bidding – whether in libertarian circles or on the right proper – has grown in recent years as part of a concerted effort by Big Tech firms to buttress against real conservatives seeking to limit the power of faceless Silicon Valley censors.

In an oped by former FTC technologist Neil Chilson, the pseudo-rightist insists Americans should be grateful to Big Tech, even when being censored, because: “You can thank innovation for The Mandalorian and for the many ways we can stay in touch: Zoom video chats, Snapchat messages and Houseparty games. Because of American tech, we can connect even while social distancing.”

Chilson made no mention of Zoom’s links to the Chinese Communist Party, Snapchat’s airing of an interview with Dr. Fauci where he encouraging casual hook-ups in the middle of the pandemic, nor Mandalorian creator Disney’s “woke” politics.

Chilson works for the Charles Koch institute, though fashions himself as a representative of “Stand Together”, which itself appears to be a external operation of the Koch network.

A full list of Google lobbyist Max Pappas’s “go to” influencers appears below. The National Pulse asked both Google and Pappas if the list represents grantees of Google, but neither responded after almost a full day:

NameKnown Affiliation/Employer
Jennifer HuddlestonAmerican Action Forum
Douglas Holtz-EakinAmerican Action Forum
Sarah HaleAmerican Action Forum
Scott FyallAmerican Enterprise Institute
Windle JarvisAmerican Enterprise Institute
Matt AuAmerican Enterprise Institute
Michael StrainAmerican Enterprise Institute
Claude BarfieldAmerican Enterprise Institute
Roslyn LaytonAmerican Enterprise Institute
Jason BertschAmerican Enterprise Institute
Gus HurwitzAmerican Enterprise Institute
Mark JamisonAmerican Enterprise Institute
Daniel LyonsAmerican Enterprise Institute
Bret SwansonAmerican Enterprise Institute
Shane TewsAmerican Enterprise Institute
James PethokoukisAmerican Enterprise Institute
Bartlett ClelandInnovation Economy Alliance
Brent GardnerAmericans for Prosperity
Billy EasleyAmericans for Prosperity
Grover NorquistAmericans for Tax Reform
Katie McAuliffeAmericans for Tax Reform
Christopher ButlerAmericans for Tax Reform
Lorenzo MontanariAmericans for Tax Reform
Alexander HendrieAmericans for Tax Reform
Jeff RoeAxiom Strategies
Norm SingletonCampaign for Liberty
Julian SanchezCATO Institute
David BoazCATO Institute
Matthew FeeneyCATO Institute
Peter Van DorenCATO Institute
Ike BrannonCATO Institute
Walter OlsonCATO Institute
John SamplesCATO Institute
Alan ReynoldsCATO Institute
Tom FireyCATO Institute
Harrison MoarCATO Institute
Jesse BlumenthalCharles Koch Institute
Neil ChilsonCharles Koch Institute
Taylor BarkleyCharles Koch Institute
Curt LeveyCommittee for Justice
Ashley BakerCommittee for Justice
Steve MooreHeritage
Phil KerpenAmerican Commitment
Kent LassmanCompetitive Enterprise Institute
Wayne CrewsCompetitive Enterprise Institute
Jessica MeluginCompetitive Enterprise Institute
Iain MurrayCompetitive Enterprise Institute
Patrick HedgerCompetitive Enterprise Institute
Christopher KoopmanGrowth Opportunity
Will RinehartGrowth Opportunity
Dean ReuterFederalist Society
Jon StaabFederalist Society
Devon WesthillFederalist Society
Alexander BiermannFederalist Society
Jason PyeFreedomworks
David BarnesAmericans for Prosperity
Tim ChapmanHeritage Action
Josh ArnoldHeritage Action
Robert BlueyHeritage
Diane KatzHeritage
Bridgett WagnerHeritage
Martin GillespieHeritage
Paul LarkinHeritage
Klon KitchenHeritage
Thomas BinionHeritage
Paul WinfreeHeritage
Jack SpencerHeritage
Amber SchwartzIndependent Women’s Forum
Carrie LukasIndependent Women’s Forum
Patrice OnwukaIndependent Women’s Forum
Nicole NeilySpeech First
Tom GiovanettiInstitute for Policy Innovation
Wayne BroughInnovation Defense
Aaron GinnLincoln Network
Garrett JohnsonLincoln Network
Zach GravesR Street
Ryan RadiaCompetitive Enterprise Institute
William UptonLincoln Network
Charles SauerMarket Institute
Adam ThiererMercatus Institute
Brent SkorupMercatus Center
Anne HobsonMercatus Institute
Andrea CastilloMercatus Institute
Matthew MitchellMercatus Institute
Andrew MoylanNational Taxpayers Union
Brandon ArnoldNational Taxpayers Union
Pete SeppNational Taxpayers Union
Genevieve McCarthyNational Taxpayers Union
Steve DelBiancoNetchoice
Carl SzaboNetchoice
Robert WintertonNetchoice
Chris MarcheseNetchoice
Lauren HylandNetchoice
Joe CoonNiskanen Center
Jerry TaylorNiskanen Center
Will WilkinsonNiskanen Center
Brink LindseyNiskanen Center
Mike GodwinR Street
Eli LehrerR Street
Thomas StrubleR Street
Arthur RizerR Street
Caleb WatneyR Street
Shoshana WeissmannR Street
Charles DuanR Street
Kevin KosarR Street
Peter SudermanReason Foundation
Berin SzokaTech Freedom
Dan BenaventeTech Freedom
Ian AdamsInternation Center for Law & Economics
Ashkhen KazaryanTech Freedom
Jim DunstanTech Freedom
Scott WallstenTech Policy Institute
Tom LenardTech Policy Institute
Glenn LammiWashington Legal Foundation
Cory AndrewsWashington Legal Foundation
Casey GivenYoung Voices
John O McGinnisFederalist Society
William ShughartThe Independent Institute
Lindsay CraigNational Review Institute
Andrea O’SullivanJames Madison Institute
Sal NuzzoJames Madison Institute
Rea HendermanBuckeye Institute
Robert AltBuckeye Institute
Asheesh AgarwalTech Freedom

UPDATE: Heritage’s Rob Bluey issued the following statement to The National Pulse, essentially confirming the think tank receives Google funds while claiming it doesn’t impact their public policy positions (which is what corporates give think tanks money for):

“The Heritage Foundation doesn’t take marching orders from anyone. We always have and always will operate according to a core set of principles when evaluating policy proposals.

Donations have zero bearing on our policy positions. Heritage’s broad base of financial support ensures that our recommendations are never influenced by outside pressure.

The Heritage Foundation’s authority rests on the quality, rigor, depth, and independent nature of our research and analysis. Any suggestion to the contrary is false.

Heritage scholars have criticized Google and other technology companies for caving to the radical left, censoring Heritage content, and pursuing ill-advised policies. We will not be pressured or bullied by anyone as we continue to represent the interests of conservatives and all Americans.”

More From The Pulse